How to Plan Your Lateral Move: Timing, Targeting, and the Story You Tell

4–6 minutes

read

Most associates think about lateraling at some point. Most don’t do it well. The lateral move is the single biggest strategic decision in a biglaw career after the original choice of firm, and almost nobody approaches it with the same rigor they brought to OCI. Here is a practical framework.

The Timing Question — When to Start Looking

The right year to lateral depends on your practice. Transactional associates are most marketable as third- to sixth-year associates. Litigation associates have a longer window — fourth through seventh year. Earlier than that, you don’t have enough experience to be worth poaching. Later than that, firms expect you to be making partner or going in-house.

The right time of year matters too. Most lateral hiring happens January through April, after bonus season closes and firms set their hiring budgets. A smaller wave runs August through September. Starting an active lateral search in November means competing against a hiring slowdown.

The wrong reasons to start: a bad week, a difficult partner, exhaustion that would feel different after vacation. Every associate has those moments. They are not lateral triggers. The right reasons are structural — a substantive mismatch with the work, no realistic path forward, a geographic or lifestyle requirement your current firm cannot meet, or a compensation issue that won’t resolve internally.

The Targeting Question — Where to Go

The shotgun approach kills lateral candidacies. Firms can tell when you’ve applied to twenty places. They want to see that you chose them.

Think about three categories. A similar firm in your league with better fit — same prestige tier, but the practice group you want or the office you want. A step down in profile for a real lifestyle or substantive reason — smaller firm, less leverage, more responsibility earlier. Or a step out entirely — in-house, boutique, government. Each requires a different story and different targeting.

The practice group you’d be joining matters more than the firm letterhead. A great group at a second-tier firm beats a mediocre group at a top firm every time. Talk to associates currently in the group before you say yes. Find out what the hours actually look like, whether the partner you’d report to is sane, and whether the work is what you think it is.

The right time to lateral is when you have a real plan — not when you’ve had a bad month.

The Story — Why You’re Leaving

This is the single most important question in every lateral interview, and most associates answer it poorly. The wrong answer is anything that sounds like complaining about your current firm. Even if your current firm is genuinely dysfunctional, you do not say that out loud. The interviewer will simply wonder what you would say about them in two years.

The right answer is forward-looking and specific. It is about what you want, not what you are leaving. “I want to do more of X kind of work” is better than “I don’t get enough X.” “I want to be in this office for family reasons” is better than “my office isn’t a good fit.” “I’m specifically interested in this practice group because of [specific reason]” is the gold standard.

If pressed on why you’re leaving, the honest version of “I want a sustainable path to partnership and this firm doesn’t have one for me” is fine. The dishonest version, where you pretend everything is great at your current firm but you just happened to apply to twelve places, is transparent and weak.

The Process Itself

Recruiters can be useful at the senior associate level for accessing firms that don’t have public lateral postings. They are usually unhelpful at the junior associate level, and they take roughly 25 percent of your first-year salary as their fee, which the receiving firm pays. That fee can be the reason a firm passes on you when they have an equally qualified direct applicant.

Direct outreach works. If you know someone at the firm you want, that warm introduction is worth more than any recruiter. Use the networking email formula from elsewhere on this site — same structure, slightly different language because you’re already an associate.

The lateral process is faster than people expect. From initial conversation to offer can be three to six weeks at firms that move quickly. Have your resume tightened, your story ready, and your references lined up before you start — not after the first call.

Confidentiality is critical. Do not tell anyone at your current firm you are looking until you have an offer in hand. The information will leak faster than you think.

Common Mistakes

Telling people at your current firm too early. Negotiating poorly on year and credit — most firms will give you the year you ask for if you ask. Taking the first offer without running a real process. Failing to do due diligence on the partner you’d be reporting to.

The biggest mistake of all: lateraling to escape a bad situation without understanding whether the new situation is actually better. The grass is sometimes greener. Often it is not. Talk to people in the group before you say yes.

The lateral move you regret is almost always the one you made in a hurry to leave somewhere, rather than to go somewhere.


Related reading

Thinking about a lateral move? Book a free 15-minute consultation to talk through your situation.

If you want to walk through your specific situation — timing, target list, the story you’ll tell — the first 15 minutes are free. More here. For a complete walkthrough of biglaw interviews including lateral, my book Biglaw Interview Advice is on Amazon.

Leave a Reply