How to Write a 1L Cover Letter That Gets You the Interview

5–7 minutes

read

1L recruiting opens December 1. If you’re a 1L, you’re probably writing cover letters this week, probably late at night, probably working off a template your career-services office handed you.

I read hundreds of these on a recruiting committee. I interviewed more than 200 candidates. And the thing I keep coming back to is how little time each letter actually got.

Nobody reads it. They skim it.

Thirty seconds, maybe less, from someone who’s tired and has forty more in the pile. That’s it. That’s the whole audience your letter is written for.

So write for that person. If they can get the point in thirty seconds, you’ve got a shot. If they have to hunt for it, they won’t.

What the reader is actually deciding

One thing: is this person worth twenty minutes of an interviewer’s time?

There are really only three things that answer it. Do you actually want this firm, or any firm? Is there a real reason you fit? And is there any evidence you can do the work?

Everything in your letter should do one of those three jobs. If a sentence doesn’t, cut it. Most cover letters are twice as long as they need to be because nobody cut anything.

Four paragraphs

First paragraph: who you are and what you want, two sentences. “I’m a first-year student applying for a 2027 summer associate position.” That’s it. Nobody needs your life story in the first line, and starting with one is the most common way to waste your best real estate.

Second paragraph: why this firm. This is the one that decides most letters, so I’ll come back to it.

Third paragraph: why you. One story, one result. I’ll come back to that too.

Fourth paragraph: ask for the interview and stop. “I would welcome the chance to discuss the position. Thank you for your consideration.” Short, confident, done.

Four paragraphs. Under one page. That’s the format. The format isn’t the hard part, the paragraphs are.

The “why this firm” paragraph

Most letters die here. The usual version reads like this: prestigious firm, collegial culture, excellent training, committed to pro bono. Every firm says that about itself. Every applicant says it about every firm. It tells me nothing, and I’ve read it a thousand times.

What worked was one specific thing. A deal the firm just closed. A case it argued. A practice group that hired three partners last month. Something you could only write about that firm.

Try this. Take your “why this firm” paragraph, swap in another firm’s name, and read it again. If it still makes sense, it isn’t really about that firm. Start over.

Finding the detail takes about fifteen minutes. The firm’s press releases, a deal announcement, a Chambers entry, a recent lateral hire. Fifteen minutes is the difference between a letter that looks like everyone else’s and one that looks like you actually want this particular job.

The “why you” paragraph

Don’t list traits. “Hardworking, detail-oriented, passionate about the law.” I read that sentence on probably half the letters that crossed my desk. Nobody believes it, because everybody writes it.

Tell me one thing you did, with an ending. The job where you figured out a broken process and fixed it. The project where you led a team that actually delivered something. The research job where you found the case nobody else found. A few sentences, with a result I can picture.

A list of adjectives is a claim. A story with a result is something I can believe. That’s the whole difference.

Five ways to get your letter deleted

The generic template is the first one. If you changed the firm name and the date and nothing else, I could tell. We all could. We read these all day.

The second is turning your resume into sentences. “In my role at X, I did A, B, and C.” Your resume already says that. The letter is for the stuff the resume can’t say.

The third is the wrong firm name. It happens more than you’d think, usually at 1 a.m. when someone is copying a template. It’s an instant no, and there’s no coming back from it. Check the name three times. Check it in the body, not just the salutation.

The fourth is opening with “I have always been passionate about the law.” So has everyone. It says nothing about you and nothing about the firm. Cut the first paragraph and start with the second one. It’ll be better.

And the fifth is length. If it’s over a page, it’s too long. If it needs five paragraphs, it isn’t tight enough. Four paragraphs, one page.

If your grades are in the middle

This is where the cover letter actually matters. A transcript is a number. The letter is the one place I saw judgment instead of a GPA.

I graduated in the middle of my class. I got interviews by being specific where everyone else was generic. If your grades are middling, the letter is where you win, because it’s the one document where the reader isn’t comparing numbers. Lead with the story, not the grades. Don’t apologize for them. Don’t mention them at all unless the firm asks.

Before you hit send

Give it ten minutes. Check the firm name, in the body and not just the top. Make sure there’s one detail in there that only works for this firm. Make sure it’s under a page. Read it out loud once, you’ll catch the sentence your eyes kept skipping. And send it from a laptop, not your phone, and check the attachment actually attached.

Ten minutes. Do it every time.

Bring me your draft

You’ve got days, not weeks. If you want another pair of eyes on yours before December 1, bring it to a free 15-minute call and we’ll fix it on the spot. You can book one on the Work With Me page.


Related reading

Working on your cover letter this week? Book a free 15-minute consultation and we’ll fix your draft on the spot before December 1.

If you want help with your cover letter or your 1L job search, the first 15 minutes are free. More here. For a complete walkthrough of biglaw interviews, from OCI through lateral, my book Biglaw Interview Advice is on Amazon.

Leave a Reply